Publication Ethics
The Journal of Educational Dynamics (JED) is an academic journal in the field of education dedicated to publishing high-quality research articles and academic articles that meet scholarly standards. The journal aims to promote the advancement of knowledge, educational innovation, and the application of knowledge for the benefit of education, society, and national development. JED places great importance on academic integrity, transparency, accountability, and ethical standards in scholarly publishing.
The journal adheres to the guidelines of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) and employs a Double-Blind Peer Review process to ensure fairness, transparency, objectivity, and freedom from bias in the evaluation and publication of manuscripts. All parties involved in the publication process, including Authors, Reviewers, and Editors, are expected to comply with the following ethical principles.
1. Duties of Authors
1.1 Originality and Exclusive Submission: Authors must ensure that the submitted manuscript is an original work and is not under consideration for publication elsewhere. If any part of the manuscript has been previously published or presented at a conference, authors must clearly disclose such information to the journal.
1.2 Accuracy of Research Reporting: Authors must present research data, findings, and interpretations accurately and honestly. Fabrication, falsification, misrepresentation of data, or selective reporting of results that may mislead readers is strictly prohibited.
1.3 Proper Citation and Referencing: Authors must appropriately acknowledge and cite the work, ideas, theories, and data of others in accordance with the journal’s referencing requirements.
1.4 Plagiarism and Redundant Publication: Authors must avoid all forms of plagiarism, duplicate publication, and salami publication, whereby a single study is inappropriately divided into multiple publications without sufficient academic justification.
1.5 Authorship: All individuals listed as authors must have made substantial contributions to the research and manuscript preparation and must approve the final version submitted for publication.
1.6 Disclosure of Funding and Conflicts of Interest: Authors must disclose all sources of research funding (if any) and any conflicts of interest that could influence the conduct of the research, data analysis, interpretation of findings, or publication decisions.
1.7 Research Ethics Approval: Research involving human participants or vulnerable populations must obtain approval from an appropriate research ethics committee prior to the commencement of the study and must comply with applicable ethical standards.
1.8 Correction of Errors: If authors discover significant errors or inaccuracies in their manuscript after submission or publication, they must promptly notify the editorial office and cooperate in correcting, clarifying, or retracting the article as appropriate.
1.9 Use of Artificial Intelligence (AI): Authors may use Artificial Intelligence (AI) tools to support writing, analysis, or manuscript preparation when appropriate. Any use of AI must be clearly disclosed in the manuscript. AI tools cannot be listed as authors, co-authors, or corresponding authors. Authors remain fully responsible for the accuracy, reliability, integrity, and appropriateness of all content contained in the manuscript.
2. Duties of Reviewers
2.1 Objectivity and Fairness: Reviewers must evaluate manuscripts objectively, fairly, and solely on academic merit without personal bias.
2.2 Confidentiality: Reviewers must treat all manuscripts and related materials as confidential documents and must not use any unpublished information for personal advantage or the benefit of others.
2.3 Conflict of Interest: Reviewers must immediately disclose any conflicts of interest or relationships that may compromise their ability to provide an impartial review.
2.4 Constructive Feedback: Reviewers should provide constructive, clear, and academically sound comments to assist authors in improving the quality of their manuscripts.
2.5 Reporting Ethical Concerns: Reviewers should notify the editorial office if they identify plagiarism, data fabrication, inappropriate citation practices, or any conduct that may constitute publication malpractice.
2.6 Timeliness: Reviewers should complete their reviews within the specified timeframe or promptly inform the editorial office if they are unable to do so.
2.7 Use of Unpublished Information: Reviewers must not disclose or use information obtained through the review process for personal benefit or the benefit of any third party.
3. Duties of Editors
3.1 Editorial Decision-Making: Editors are responsible for evaluating manuscripts based on academic merit, originality, validity, reliability, and relevance to the journal’s scope and objectives.
3.2 Fair and Impartial Evaluation: Editors must evaluate manuscripts fairly and without discrimination based on gender, age, race, religion, nationality, institutional affiliation, or academic viewpoints.
3.3 Confidentiality: Editors must maintain the confidentiality of authors, reviewers, and all information related to submitted manuscripts throughout the review and publication process.
3.4 Selection of Reviewers: Editors must appoint qualified reviewers with appropriate expertise and without conflicts of interest related to the manuscript under consideration.
3.5 Editorial Conflicts of Interest: Editors must refrain from handling manuscripts in which they have conflicts of interest or relationships that could affect impartial decision-making. In such cases, editorial responsibility should be assigned to another editor.
3.6 Similarity Screening: Editors must screen manuscripts for textual similarity using appropriate plagiarism-detection tools before initiating the peer-review process. Manuscripts exceeding the journal’s acceptable similarity threshold may be returned for revision or rejected.
3.7 Addressing Ethical Misconduct: Editors must follow COPE guidelines when handling complaints, ethical concerns, plagiarism, data fabrication, falsification, or other forms of publication malpractice.
3.8 Corrections and Retractions: Editors have the authority to reject, correct, retract, or remove published articles when ethical violations or significant inaccuracies are identified, in accordance with accepted scholarly publishing standards.
3.9 Promotion of Academic Quality: Editors are committed to promoting high-quality educational scholarship, the development of new knowledge, and the advancement of educational professions in accordance with national and international standards.
4. Complaints and Publication Malpractice
4.1 Complaint Handling Procedures: The journal maintains procedures for receiving, investigating, and resolving complaints related to publication ethics and publication malpractice in a fair, transparent, and accountable manner.
4.2 Investigation of Ethical Concerns: When complaints or suspected ethical violations are received, the editorial board will investigate the matter in accordance with COPE guidelines and provide all relevant parties with an opportunity to respond.
4.3 Actions in Cases of Misconduct: If plagiarism, data fabrication, data falsification, copyright infringement, or other forms of publication malpractice are confirmed, the journal may reject, correct, retract, or otherwise take appropriate action regarding the manuscript or published article.
4.4 Ethical Governance: All editorial decisions and actions concerning publication ethics shall be conducted in accordance with COPE principles, accepted scholarly publishing standards, and principles of academic good governance. Relevant parties will be informed of decisions and outcomes as appropriate.
Last Updated: June 2026
Journal of Educational Dynamics (JED